Why is the distinction hard?
How common, and how severe?
Blueprint vs. wrecking ball. Malformation = wrong blueprint (can be handed to the next child). Disruption = a wrecking ball hit a correctly built house (usually won't happen again).
Anterior neuropore = cranial end (brain) → anencephaly. Posterior neuropore = caudal end (spinal cord) → myelomeningocele. Don't flip them because "posterior" sounds like "back of the head".
| Defect | What is wrong | Clues | AFP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spina bifida occulta | Mildest; tail-bud (secondary neurulation) defect; bony arch gap; skin closed | Tuft of hair, sacral dimple/sinus, skin tag, attached lipoma; may have hydromyelia, diastematomyelia, tethered cord | Normal |
| Meningocele | Abnormal axial mesoderm → bony defect; meninges only herniate into a CSF sac; cord and central canal stay closed | Skin-covered sac; neurologically mild | Usually normal (↑ if open) |
| Myelomeningocele | Most severe spinal NTD: failure of posterior neural tube closure + bony defect; meninges + cord in the sac | Lumbosacral; area medullovasculosa; Chiari II + hydrocephalus | ↑↑ |
| Encephalocele | Brain ± meninges herniate through a cranial bony defect (cranial meningocele if meninges only) | Usually occipital; skin ulceration, infection | ↑ if open |
| Anencephaly | Failure of anterior neuropore; absent cranial vault; exposed brain degenerates | Area cerebrovasculosa; froglike face; polyhydramnios | ↑↑ |
| Craniorachischisis | Whole tube open, brain + cord | Most extreme; lethal | ↑↑ |
| Group | Members | Failed step |
|---|---|---|
| Neural tube defects (dysraphic) | Anencephaly, encephalocele, myelomeningocele, meningocele, spina bifida (occulta) | Neurulation (wk 3–4) |
| Chiari malformations | Chiari I, II, III | Posterior fossa / hindbrain development |
| Disorders of forebrain induction | Holoprosencephaly | Prosencephalon cleavage (wk 5–6) |
| Neuronal migration disorders | Lissencephaly type I (agyria/pachygyria), polymicrogyria, heterotopia, focal cortical dysplasia | Neuron proliferation, migration, organization (≈wk 8–24) |
| Other | Cerebellum, brainstem and cord malformations (e.g., Dandy-Walker); hydrocephalus | Various |
"Close → Cleave → Climb → Construct." Tube closes (NTDs) → forebrain cleaves (holoprosencephaly) → neurons climb to the cortex (lissencephaly, heterotopia) → cortex is constructed into layers (polymicrogyria, FCD).
"Spina bifida" on Step 1 can mean either occulta (normal AFP, asymptomatic) or cystica (meningocele / myelomeningocele). Read for skin (intact vs open) and neuro deficits (none vs leg weakness, neurogenic bladder).
| Form | Brain | Face |
|---|---|---|
| Alobar (most severe) | Very small, helmet-shaped holosphere not divided into hemispheres; single monoventricle with a thin dorsal membrane; absent olfactory bulbs and hypophysis; no corpus callosum, no septum pellucidum; fused basal ganglia/thalami; hippocampal formation rims the ventricle; bizarre, radiating gyral pattern. Cerebellum keeps two hemispheres. | Cyclopia (fused orbits/eyes), proboscis (ethmocephaly), cebocephaly (flat nose, single nostril), hypotelorism, microphthalmia, agnathia |
| Semilobar | Shallow interhemispheric fissure (posteriorly); no corpus callosum; cortex continuous across the midline frontally | Hypotelorism, midline cleft lip/palate |
| Lobar (mildest) | Hemispheres mostly separate; no corpus callosum; cortex continuous across the midline at the frontal pole/orbital surface | Mild hypotelorism, single central incisor |
"The face predicts the brain." Cyclops eye → alobar. One front tooth → lobar. Read the face like a severity dial.
Pachygyria = few, broad gyri (pachy = thick). Polymicrogyria = many, small gyri. Opposite surfaces, both migration/organization disorders. Lissencephaly type II (cobblestone) is a different disease (over-migration through a broken pial surface; e.g., FCMD/fukutin).
| Lesion | Histology | Extent | Clinical |
|---|---|---|---|
| FCD type IIa | Dysmorphic neurons, dyslamination, no balloon cells | Focal | Childhood epilepsy |
| FCD type IIb | Dysmorphic neurons + balloon cells | Focal | Drug-resistant focal epilepsy; resection |
| Cortical tuber (tuberous sclerosis) | Same as FCD IIb + calcification, bizarre giant cells | Multiple firm, potato-like cortical thickenings; blurred grey–white junction | Seizures, ID; resect only if driving epilepsy |
| Hemimegalencephaly | FCD-type histology | Whole enlarged hemisphere | Continuous, drug-resistant seizures from infancy |
Balloon = "blown-up glass": big, glassy pink cytoplasm with the nucleus pushed to the edge, like the knot at the end of a balloon.
A question that pairs ↑ MSAFP with "maternal diabetes" or "↑ HbA1c" usually wants the NTD, not diabetes. Pregestational diabetes does raise NTD risk, but its signature CNS anomalies are caudal regression and holoprosencephaly. Answer the lab question with ↑ AFP / ↑ AChE.
| Feature | Chiari I | Chiari II (Arnold-Chiari) | Dandy-Walker |
|---|---|---|---|
| What's wrong | Cerebellar tonsils herniate >3–5 mm below the foramen magnum | Small posterior fossa; vermis + tonsils + elongated medulla pushed through the foramen magnum; tectal beaking | Absent/hypoplastic vermis + cystic 4th ventricle filling an enlarged posterior fossa |
| Age | Adolescent / adult | Infant (prenatal) | Infant |
| Key association | Syringomyelia (cervical), occipital headache, cerebellar signs | Lumbosacral myelomeningocele (>95%), hydrocephalus (aqueductal stenosis), hydromyelia | Hydrocephalus; other malformations |
| Severity | Often mild or asymptomatic | Severe: brainstem dysfunction (stridor, apnea, swallowing) | Variable |
| Posterior fossa size | Normal/small | Small | Large |
A cervical syrinx (Chiari I) expands the central canal and first destroys the anterior white commissure (crossing spinothalamic fibers) → bilateral, cape-like loss of pain and temperature over the shoulders and arms with preserved vibration/proprioception. Expansion into the anterior horns → LMN wasting of the hands; lateral columns → UMN signs in the legs.
Chiari "1, 2" counts the structures: Chiari 1 → 1 structure (tonsils). Chiari 2 → 2+ structures (vermis + medulla) and 2 companions (myelomeningocele + hydrocephalus). Dandy-Walker = Dilated 4th ventricle, Without a vermis.
CSF path: lateral ventricles → foramina of Monro → 3rd ventricle → cerebral aqueduct → 4th ventricle → foramina of Luschka (lateral) and Magendie (median) → subarachnoid space → arachnoid granulations → dural venous sinus.
Block inside the ventricular system. Ventricles dilate upstream of the block.
e.g., aqueductal stenosis in Chiari II; Dandy-Walker; clot in the aqueduct after germinal matrix hemorrhage; SEGA at Monro.
↓ CSF absorption at arachnoid granulations; all ventricles dilate.
e.g., scarring after hemorrhage or meningitis.
Ventricles look big because brain tissue was lost, not because CSF is trapped. Normal pressure.
e.g., multicystic encephalopathy, atrophy.
Big ventricles + small brain / microcephaly = ex vacuo, not obstructive. Don't shunt a brain that's simply missing tissue.
| Abnormality | CNS malformation | Other clues |
|---|---|---|
| 5p− (cri-du-chat) | Microcephaly | High-pitched cat-like cry, ID |
| Trisomy 13 (Patau) | Holoprosencephaly | Cleft lip/palate, postaxial polydactyly, microphthalmia, cutis aplasia |
| Trisomy 18 (Edwards) | Microcephaly | Clenched overlapping fingers, rocker-bottom feet, micrognathia |
| Trisomy 21 (Down) | Microcephaly | Flat facies, single palmar crease; early Alzheimer |
| 45,X (Turner) | Defects of cerebellum and basal ganglia | Short stature, webbed neck |
| Gene (protein) | Inheritance | Malformation / syndrome |
|---|---|---|
| SHH (sonic hedgehog, 7q36) | AD (variable) | Holoprosencephaly (HPE3); also SIX3 (2p21, homeobox), ZIC2 (13q32) |
| LIS1 = PAFAH1B1 (17p13.3) | AD (deletion) | Lissencephaly type I, posterior-predominant; encodes the non-catalytic subunit of platelet-activating factor acetylhydrolase; with neighboring genes → Miller-Dieker |
| DCX (doublecortin, Xq22) | X-linked | Males: lissencephaly, anterior-predominant (± agenesis of corpus callosum). Females: subcortical band heterotopia |
| RELN (reelin, 7q22) | AR | Lissencephaly + cerebellar and hippocampal hypoplasia (ataxia, ID, seizures) |
| ARX (X) | X-linked | Male lissencephaly + ambiguous genitalia, corpus callosum agenesis, severe seizures, temperature dysregulation |
| FLNA (filamin A) | X-linked | Periventricular nodular heterotopia with epilepsy |
| FCMD (fukutin) | AR | Lissencephaly type II (cobblestone), polymicrogyria; Fukuyama congenital muscular dystrophy |
| GPR56 | AR | Bilateral frontoparietal polymicrogyria |
| KAL1 (anosmin) | X-linked | Absent olfactory bulbs + no GnRH neurons → Kallmann syndrome |
| PAX6 | AD | Aniridia; homozygotes → severe neuronal migration disorder |
| UBE3A | Imprinting (maternal) | Microcephaly, cerebellar atrophy → Angelman syndrome |
| TSC1/TSC2 | AD | Cortical tubers, subependymal nodules, SEGA (tuberous sclerosis) |
| MTOR, PIK3CA, AKT3 (somatic) | Mosaic | FCD II, hemimegalencephaly (mTOR pathway overactivity) |
LIS1 Lies in the back, DCX Drives in front. LIS1 → posterior smooth brain; DCX → anterior. And DCX = "Double Cortex X-linked".
Kallmann (anosmia + hypogonadotropic hypogonadism) is a neuronal migration problem (GnRH neurons fail to migrate from the olfactory placode), not a pituitary tumor. And Angelman (UBE3A, maternal) vs Prader-Willi (paternal deletion) at 15q11-13: don't flip the parent.
| Defect | Outcome | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Anencephaly | Incompatible with prolonged life: stillbirth or death within hours–days | None (comfort care) |
| Encephalocele | Depends on size/contents; small ones compatible with life | Surgical repair |
| Meningocele | Compatible with life; usually good function | Surgical correction |
| Myelomeningocele | Survives; deficits set by level; hydrocephalus, Chiari II, neurogenic bladder | In-utero closure → better neurologic function + less shunting; otherwise early postnatal closure + VP shunt |
| Occulta | Usually asymptomatic | Release of tethered cord if symptomatic |
Sources differ on the unaided-walking cutoff ("below S1" vs "below S2"). The idea is what's tested: low sacral lesions walk, high lumbar/thoracic lesions don't.
Alobar: stillbirth or early death. Survivors: severe developmental delay, spasticity, seizures, apnea, temperature instability, pituitary deficits (diabetes insipidus). Lobar can be mild.
Tx: supportive; hormone replacement; feeding support.
Profound ID and motor delay; infantile spasms and intractable epilepsy; feeding problems/aspiration; many die in childhood.
Tx: antiseizure drugs, gastrostomy, supportive.
Seizures, ID, swallowing problems (bilateral perisylvian → pseudobulbar palsy), spasticity; varies with extent.
Drug-resistant epilepsy + developmental delay.
Tx: surgical resection of the FCD focus (often seizure-free); hemispherectomy for hemimegalencephaly.
Epilepsy, ID, autism; SEGA → hydrocephalus.
Tx: tubers resected only if they drive epilepsy; vigabatrin for infantile spasms; everolimus for SEGA.
"Focal → knife; diffuse → drugs and support."
| Source | Causes of asphyxia (before, during or after delivery) |
|---|---|
| Maternal | Severe antepartum hemorrhage, shock (abruption), cardiac arrest, anemia, hypertension/toxemia, diabetes, autoimmune disease, intrauterine infection, smoking, trauma |
| Placental | Infarcts, hemorrhage, infection (villitis), short cord or long cord around the neck |
| Fetal | Congenital malformations (CNS, respiratory, neuromuscular, heart), metabolic disease |
"Mom, Placenta, Baby": every asphyxia cause sits in one of three boxes. Run through all three when a vignette gives you a damaged newborn.
Grade 2 vs 3 hinges on one word: distension. Blood in the ventricle with normal size = 2; blood with dilated ventricles = 3. And a term baby with a bleed is not a germinal matrix bleed (the matrix is gone); think trauma, coagulopathy, vitamin K deficiency, or venous thrombosis.
Preterm + periventricular white matter infarcts + chalky yellow foci with calcification → later spastic diplegia (legs > arms). Ultrasound: periventricular echodensities → cysts at 2–6 weeks.
CMV also gives periventricular lesions, but as periventricular calcifications with microcephaly, chorioretinitis and sensorineural deafness, not watershed infarcts after a hypotensive preemie course. Toxoplasmosis → diffuse (parenchymal) calcifications.
| Feature | Germinal matrix hemorrhage | PVL (white matter necrosis) | Multicystic encephalopathy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who | Preterm, esp. <30 wk, ventilated | Preterm 24–32 wk | 3rd trimester / term / postnatal |
| Mechanism | Fragile capillaries + loss of autoregulation + BP swings + fibrinolysis | Watershed ischemia + inflammation → pre-oligodendrocyte death | Severe global hypoxia-ischemia → liquefactive necrosis |
| Location | Subependymal over caudate → ventricles → white matter | Periventricular white matter | Cortex + white matter, both hemispheres |
| Gross | Clot in matrix/ventricle; dilated ventricles | Chalky white-yellow foci → small cysts | Multiple cysts, spider's web bands, ex-vacuo ventricles |
| Micro | Blood, then hemosiderin, cystic cavity | Coagulative necrosis, spheroids, calcification | Cavities, gliosis, calcium, dilated vessels |
| Main sequel | Post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus | Spastic diplegia | Microcephaly, quadriplegia, epilepsy, early death |
Brain infarcts undergo liquefactive necrosis (high lipid, few structural proteins, abundant lysosomal enzymes) → cysts. Contrast coagulative necrosis in heart, kidney, spleen.
History: preterm, ventilated, RDS, resuscitation, BP swings; first 3–24 h.
Signs: often silent; or sudden deterioration: bulging fontanelle, ↓ hematocrit, hypotension, apnea, seizures, hypotonia.
Imaging: cranial ultrasound → echogenic blood in the matrix/ventricles; later enlarging ventricles.
History: preterm 24–32 wk; hypotension, sepsis, chorioamnionitis.
Signs: often quiet in the NICU → stiff, scissoring legs and delayed walking by 1–2 years.
Imaging: periventricular echodensities → cysts; MRI: periventricular white matter loss, irregular ventricles.
History: ↓ fetal movement, co-twin death in utero, placental infarcts/villitis with late prenatal care (placental cause), congenital heart disease (fetal cause), low Apgar, apnea at birth.
Signs from birth: seizures, hypertonia, irritability, abnormal cry, microcephaly → death in weeks, months or years.
Imaging: global ischemic injury, cortical abnormalities, ex-vacuo ventricles.
| Clue | Points to malformation | Points to perinatal injury |
|---|---|---|
| History | Normal pregnancy/birth; family history; consanguinity | Prematurity, difficult labor, abruption, low Apgar, ventilation |
| Exam | Dysmorphic face, other organ anomalies | Signs began at/after a hypoxic event |
| Pathology | Wrong architecture (no gyri, extra gyri, heterotopia, no midline split) | Destroyed normal architecture: cysts, gliosis, calcification, hemosiderin |
| Recurrence | May recur (genetic counseling) | Usually low |
Malformation = "never built right." Injury = "built right, then broken." Look for the broken pieces (cysts, scar, calcium, iron) to call injury.
A "floppy, seizing newborn" is not always asphyxia. Inborn errors (nonketotic hyperglycinemia, pyridoxine-dependent epilepsy, mitochondrial disease, urea cycle defects) can look like HIE. Clues: no sentinel event, normal cord gases, consanguinity, worsening after feeds, high ammonia/lactate.
Hypoxia → ATP failure → Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase fails → depolarization → glutamate release + ↓ reuptake → NMDA receptor Ca²⁺ influx → proteases, lipases, NO, free radicals → neuronal death. Most vulnerable neurons: hippocampus (CA1), Purkinje cells, neocortical layers 3, 5, 6. Red neurons (eosinophilic cytoplasm, pyknotic nuclei) appear 12–24 h after injury.
Small bleeds may resolve (grade 1 can leave a cystic cavity / small subependymal cyst after the bleed). Mostly good outcome, small ↑ risk of mild delay.
Blood clots and organizes in the aqueduct, 4th-ventricle foramina or arachnoid granulations → post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus (may need a shunt); developmental delay.
Very severe: high mortality or profound deficits; periventricular hemorrhagic infarction → porencephalic cyst, spastic hemiplegia, epilepsy, ID.
"Legs hug the ventricle." Leg fibers run closest to the lateral ventricle, so periventricular damage hits them first → diplegia (two legs).
| Lesion | Short-term | Long-term | Prevention / treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Germinal matrix hemorrhage | Shock, anemia, apnea, seizures, death (grade 3–4) | Post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus, hemiplegia (grade 4), CP, ID, epilepsy | Antenatal steroids, avoid BP swings, delayed cord clamping; serial ultrasound; CSF drainage → VP shunt |
| PVL | Often silent | Spastic diplegia, visual impairment, cognitive/attention problems | Prevent preterm birth/infection; antenatal magnesium sulfate lowers CP risk; physiotherapy, botulinum toxin, baclofen |
| Multicystic encephalopathy | Seizures, hypertonia, abnormal cry, feeding failure | Microcephaly, quadriplegia, epilepsy, death in weeks–years | Supportive; therapeutic hypothermia (≥36 wk with moderate-severe HIE, start <6 h) aims to prevent this outcome |
Choreoathetosis after a perinatal insult: if there was severe jaundice, think kernicterus (globus pallidus, subthalamic nucleus); if there was an acute sentinel event at term, think basal ganglia–thalamic HIE. Same movement disorder, different cause.
1A 27-year-old woman at 17 weeks' gestation has an elevated maternal serum α-fetoprotein. Amniotic fluid shows elevated AFP and acetylcholinesterase. Ultrasound shows an open lumbosacral sac containing neural tissue, scalloped frontal bones and a cerebellum curved around the brainstem. Which additional finding is most likely in this infant after birth?
2A 24-year-old woman with juvenile myoclonic epilepsy well controlled on valproic acid plans to conceive within a year. Her previous pregnancy ended because of anencephaly. Which measure would most reduce the risk of a neural tube defect in her next pregnancy?
3A newborn has hypotelorism, a single central maxillary incisor and a flat nose with a single nostril. MRI shows partial fusion of the frontal lobes and absence of the corpus callosum. Karyotype is 46,XY. His mother has mild hypotelorism. A defect in which signaling pathway is most likely responsible?
4A 2-year-old boy has infantile spasms, severe developmental delay and hypotonia. MRI shows a smooth cerebral surface that is most severe in the frontal lobes. His mother has had focal seizures since adolescence, and her MRI shows a continuous band of grey matter deep to a normal-appearing cortex. Which gene is most likely mutated?
5A 4-month-old girl has feeding difficulty, hypotonia and frequent seizures. Examination shows microcephaly, bitemporal hollowing, a small jaw and a short nose. MRI shows near-complete agyria, worst in the parieto-occipital regions. Which genetic finding is most likely?
6A 7-year-old boy has had daily focal seizures since age 3 despite three antiseizure drugs. He has no skin lesions and no family history. MRI shows thickening of one frontal gyrus with a blurred grey–white junction. The lesion is resected. Microscopy shows loss of cortical lamination, large misoriented neurons with clumped Nissl substance, and large cells with glassy eosinophilic cytoplasm and eccentric nuclei. What is the diagnosis?
7A 9-month-old has clusters of flexor spasms. Examination shows several hypopigmented, leaf-shaped macules on the trunk. Echocardiography shows multiple intracardiac masses. MRI shows multiple cortical lesions with blurring of the grey–white junction and nodules along the lateral ventricles. Loss of function of the affected gene product most directly leads to which of the following?
8A boy born at 26 weeks is mechanically ventilated for respiratory distress syndrome. On day 2 he becomes hypotensive and bradycardic; the anterior fontanelle is bulging and the hematocrit has fallen from 46% to 33%. Cranial ultrasound shows echogenic material filling dilated lateral ventricles. Where did the hemorrhage most likely begin?
9A 2-year-old boy born at 28 weeks after maternal chorioamnionitis cannot walk independently. His legs are spastic with brisk reflexes, bilateral Babinski signs and scissoring; arm function and language are near normal. MRI shows reduced periventricular white matter and irregular lateral ventricles. Which mechanism best explains his condition?
10A monochorionic twin pregnancy is complicated by the death of one twin at 33 weeks. The surviving girl is delivered at 36 weeks with seizures, hypertonia, an abnormal cry and microcephaly. She dies at 3 months. At autopsy the brain weighs half of normal; coronal sections show the hemispheres replaced by multiple cavities crossed by fine strands of tissue, and the ventricles are enlarged. Microscopy shows gliosis, calcification and dilated vessels. Which diagnosis is most likely?
11A 15-year-old girl has 6 months of occipital headaches worsened by coughing, unsteady gait and recent urinary urgency. She has loss of pain and temperature sensation over the shoulders and upper arms bilaterally, with preserved vibration and position sense, and wasting of the hand muscles. Which finding is most likely on MRI?
12A 3-month-old has a tuft of dark hair over the lumbosacral spine. Neurologic examination is normal, and the skin is intact. His mother's prenatal screening was normal. Imaging shows a defect of the L5 posterior vertebral arch with normal meninges and cord. Which of the following best describes this lesion?
13A 31-year-old woman presents in preterm labor at 27 weeks. Delivery appears likely within 24–48 hours. Administration of which drug to the mother now would most reduce the newborn's risk of intraventricular hemorrhage?